What we'd aim for first, based on difficulty
Local legal searches are not equally hard. In our SEO OS, “personal injury lawyer fort myers” has a keyword difficulty of 51 out of 100 and “attorney fort myers” 44. The same searches in Collier and Cape Coral are much softer: “attorney naples” scores 6 and “attorney cape coral” 19 (keyword data from our SEO OS, Nov 2026).
So a new firm site rarely starts with the hardest phrase. We'd build the practice-area pages first, win the softer city and case-type searches, collect reviews, and let that authority carry the page for the big term. A Fort Myers injury firm, for example, can often rank for a specific case type like motorcycle accidents, or for a Naples variant, well before the head term moves.
The Map Pack works differently from the organic results. Google weighs how close the searcher is to your office, so a Fort Myers office rarely appears in the map for someone standing on Fifth Avenue South in Naples. That's where a city page and organic rankings do the work, and where a staffed second office, if you have one, deserves its own profile.